The Inward Beauty of Helmut Lachenmann

Lachenmann at 75: Inward Beauty PosterIn cel­eb­ra­tion of Helmut Lachenmann’s 75th birthday, University of Manchester new music en­semble Vaganza are presenting two con­certs of his music this Friday. A free lunch­time con­cert will see Ad Solem Chamber Choir per­form Lachenmann’s Consolation II along­side works by stu­dents, in­cluding Tom Coult and Joy Chou. The evening sees a more thor­ough ex­am­in­a­tion of Lachenmann’s early music with per­form­ances of Trio fluido, Guero, Wiegenmusik and Notturno. To com­plete the focus, former stu­dent and scholar of Lachenmann Matthias Hermann, from the Musikhochschule Stuttgart, is giving a talk at 2pm on the Thursday on com­pos­i­tion tech­niques in Notturno. That is fol­lowed at 4.15pm by a panel dis­cus­sion and open forum on the im­port­ance of timbre as a struc­tural para­meter in con­tem­porary music.

For those of you equipped with 2011 di­aries, it is also worth noting that Lachenmann’s temA will be per­formed by Trio Atem (formed for that very work) on 17 March and the university’s string quartet in res­id­ence Quatuor Danel will be per­forming all three Lachenmann quar­tets between January and May. I will be talking with the Danels on that very topic on 20 January.

I was asked to write pro­gramme notes for the Lachenmann works being per­formed this Friday and thought it might be in­ter­esting to post them here, along with videos or re­cord­ings where avail­able. However, this is music to which first-hand listening is es­sen­tial, so I would urge you to get to the Martin Harris Centre later this week.

Concert 1 (1.10pm)

Consolation II, for 16 voices (1968)

The late ‘60s saw Lachenmann focus heavily on writing for voice, com­posing Consolations I and II (1967 and ’68 re­spect­ively) and the trio temA, for flute, voice and cello (1968), some­thing he didn’t re­turn to until the 1990s with his opera Das Mädchen mit den Schwefelhölzern (1990−96). It has been sug­gested that in periods of rapid de­vel­op­ment the phys­ic­ality of the voice and the frame­work of a text have sup­ported avant-garde com­posers in their ex­per­i­ment­a­tion. Arnold Schoenberg led the way with works such as Pierrot lun­aire and the Vier Lieder für Gesang und Orchester at cru­cial points in his de­vel­op­ment, the same can be said of Anton Webern, and later Pierre Boulez, Luciano Berio and Luigi Nono all turned to the voice at turning points in their re­spective mu­sical lan­guages. The late ‘60s marks Lachenmann’s coming of age as a com­poser and the de­vel­op­ment of the first stage of his ma­ture style, so per­haps it is no sur­prise that he found him­self be­gin­ning to ex­plore his newly coined idea of ‘mu­sique con­crète in­stru­mentale’ with the help of singers.

Consolation II sets an eighth-century prayer known as the Wessobrunner Gebet and, in a fashion not un­common for the 1960s, frag­ments the se­mantic ma­terial, leaving only the phon­etic ma­terial ex­posed as the bare bones of the text. The prayer’s med­it­a­tion on finding God in the noth­ing­ness be­fore time is dis­solved into a shud­dering land­scape of let­ters, hissing with a hollow wind, shiv­ering with rolled ‘R’s, stut­tering away into the noth­ing­ness where God can per­haps be found, ending on the ‘t’ of ‘Gott’, not sung but struck: two fin­gers coming to­gether in a quiet clap.

Mir gestand der Sterblichen Staunen als Höchstes
Das Erde nicht war, noch oben Himmel
Noch Baum, noch ir­gend ein Berg nicht war
Noch die Sonne, nicht Licht war
Noch der Mond nicht leuchtete
Noch das ge­waltige Meer
Da noch nir­gends nichts war
An Enden und Wenden
Da war der eine all­mächtige Gott

Mortal wonder as the greatest was con­fided in me
That there was neither the earth nor the heaven above
Nor was there any tree nor moun­tain
Neither the sun, nor any light
Nor the moon gleam
Nor the glor­ious sea.
When there was nothing
No ending and no limits
There was the One Almighty God

Concert 2 (7.30pm)

Trio fluido, for cla­rinet, viola and per­cus­sion (1966)

Though written six years after Lachenmann left Venice and full-time study with Luigi Nono, Trio fluido is still heavily in­flu­enced by Nono’s punc­tu­alist music. Rather than ac­cepting this concept fully, it ex­plores the various po­ten­tial de­vel­op­ments of and es­capes from such point-to-point writing. In the course of the work the sep­ar­ated se­quence of sounds is gradu­ally both dis­solved and para­lysed, pushing the music at dif­ferent points into the ex­treme world of sparse, sep­ar­ated ges­tures common in his music as well as a more con­tinuous, co­hesive tex­ture of blown, bowed, rubbed and stroked sounds. The kind of ges­tural ma­terial that is in­creas­ingly vital in Lachenmann’s later music is fore­shad­owed in Trio fluido by a form of pitch ges­ture where in­stru­ments move through nar­rower and wider fields of pitch, and the el­ev­ated im­port­ance of in­stru­mental tech­niques and phys­ical ges­ture also fore­shadow his more com­plete move away from pitch that began not long after this piece was completed.

Guero — Study for Piano (1970)

Between 1968 and ’70, Lachenmann de­veloped a more defined ver­sion of his lan­guage to de­scribe which he coined the phrase ‘mu­sique con­crète in­stru­mentale’. Having spent time during 1965 at the elec­tronic music stu­dios of the University of Ghent and written his only purely elec­tronic piece Szenario, Lachenmann bor­rowed tape music pi­oneer Pierre Schaefer’s term ‘mu­sique con­crète’ meaning music con­structed with con­crete sound re­cord­ings rather than ab­stract not­ated struc­tures and for­mu­lated a com­pos­i­tional ap­proach that treated in­stru­ments and per­formed ges­tures as con­crete phys­ical in­stances, the en­ergy of whose per­form­ance formed the struc­ture of a work.

While de­vel­oping this idea he wrote a series of solo studies that in­clude Guero as well as Pression, for cello, and Dal ni­ente, for cla­rinet. Each of these studies take as their starting point a thor­ough ex­plor­a­tion of the instrument’s acoustic pos­sib­il­ities — in­spired by a col­lec­tion of short piano pieces by Alfons Kontarsky — and pro­ceeds to build struc­tures that re­veal the mech­an­isms of per­form­ance. In his pro­gramme note, Lachenmann de­scribes Guero as a ‘six-manual variant of the eponymous Latin American in­stru­ment’. The piece moves from the ver­tical sur­faces of the white keys, to their ho­ri­zontal sur­faces, via the black keys into the piano, playing the pegs and fi­nally the strings. An ex­treme ex­ample of Lachenmann’s concept of re­jec­tion — in which all fa­miliar as­pects of tra­di­tional in­stru­mental tech­nique are avoided — Guero is an at­tempt to build struc­ture not from ex­isting for­mulas but from the ground up, taking the con­crete, rip­pling sound of the fin­ger­nails along the keys as its basic material.

Wiegenmusik [Cradle music], for piano (1963)

Trained ori­gin­ally as a clas­sical pi­anist and still per­forming, Helmut Lachenmann has al­ways had an im­portant com­pos­i­tional re­la­tion­ship with the piano, having written a dozen solo, chamber and con­cer­tante works for the in­stru­ment. One of the earliest works still in­cluded in the of­fi­cial Lachenmann cata­logue, Wiegenmusik is an early ex­ample of Lachenmann’s par­tic­ular in­terest in stasis as a mu­sical phe­nomenon. Unlike the re­pet­itive stasis of Steve Reich or the weight­less stasis of Morton Feldman, Lachenmann uses sparse tex­tures to in­duce an at­mo­sphere of ten­sion and draw at­ten­tion to small, pre­cise, richly de­tailed sounds. Later works such as the Second String Quartet ‘Reigen se­liger Geister’ (1989) or Mouvement (— vor der Erstarrung) (1982−84), for en­semble — which makes its theme (the shift from move­ment to para­lysis) evident in its title — both take this concept to lo­gical ex­tremes. Consolation II and Notturno, both of which are per­formed to­night, also make use of this type of writing. In Wiegenmusik, Lachenmann takes a gentle ap­proach, drawing on the idea of a child falling asleep as the work gradu­ally falls into still­ness. Like his earlier pieces for piano, Fünf Variationen über ein Thema von Franz Schubert (1956) and Echo Andante (1962), Wiegenmusik still treats the piano in a re­l­at­ively tra­di­tional fashion. As you have heard, by 1970 with Guero Lachenmann was finding an al­to­gether dif­ferent way of making sound with a piano.

Notturno, for small or­chestra with cello solo (1966−68)


Helmut Lachenmann writes of Notturno that it is ‘a meeting point for two dif­ferent aes­thetics: one older, which treats sound as the result and ex­pres­sion of ab­stract or­gan­isa­tion con­cepts, and one newer, in which all or­gan­isa­tion should serve a con­crete and direct acoustic reality.’ The cello writing is close to the solo cello work Pression written the fol­lowing year — for the same cel­list, Italo Gomez — and mainly takes the latter ap­proach, ex­ploring the acoustic po­ten­tial of the cello ap­proached not as a tra­di­tional in­stru­ment but as a mul­ti­fa­ceted sounding body.

Despite the ex­tended solo pas­sage that makes up the core of the work, the cello’s role is not so much as tra­di­tional so­loist ac­com­panied by a sub­ser­vient or­chestra but as a kind of leader and opener of doors, drawing the en­semble into dif­ferent worlds and un­cov­ering new per­spect­ives. In a sense, the work is for a meta cello or ex­tended cello as the en­semble all con­tribute to a uni­fied sound, led and de­rived from the cello proper, a powerful real­isa­tion of Lachenmann’s sug­ges­tion that ‘com­posing means building an in­stru­ment’ and an in­triguing take on the con­cer­tante tradition.

Posted in Odds & Ends | Tagged , , | Comments (1)

[…] and every at­tempt
Is a wholly new start, and a dif­ferent kind of failure
Because one has only learnt to get the better of words
For the thing one no longer has to say, or the way in which
One is no longer dis­posed to say it. […]

— T.S. Eliot, ‘East Coker’, Four Quartets

Posted in Odds & Ends | Tagged , | Comments Off on

Composer Portrait:
Nina Whiteman

With re­cent premi­eres by Dutch ac­cor­dion duo TOEAC, Colinton Amateur Orchestral Society, Manchester Camerata and period in­stru­ment trio Spirituoso, 29-year-old com­poser Nina Whiteman has had a busy year, not men­tioning per­form­ances as a vo­calist with her flute, voice and cello group, Trio Atem, whose most re­cent per­form­ance was the premiere of graphic scores by artist Michael Mayhew at Manchester’s Whitworth Art Gallery and who make their London debut in April at Kings Place.

You can cur­rently see and hear Nina’s re­cent Manchester Camerata com­mis­sion, Windows on the Neva, over on medici.tv [link ex­pired]. Scored for a single-stringed chamber or­chestra, the work is an 8-minute re­flec­tion on the river Neva’s in­ex­or­able path through the city of St. Petersburg whose lucid tex­tures and well-controlled pa­cing re­veal a com­poser with a keen ear for both sound and drama. In the first of what will hope­fully be­come an oc­ca­sional series of en­coun­ters with mu­si­cians, Nina has kindly answered some ques­tions about her music, prac­tice and fu­ture plans, so read on to find out what makes her tick. Read More »

Posted in Composer Profiles | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Composer Portrait:
Nina Whiteman

Points of Contact: MANTIS Fall Festival 2010

The bi­an­nual MANTIS Festival at the University of Manchester presents fixed media works and works with live elec­tronics, per­forming these over a large sound dif­fu­sion system that com­prises around 40 loud­speakers. The con­certs over the Halloween weekend show­cased the work of stu­dents at the uni­ver­sity, that of in­vited guest com­posers and in­cluded the first col­lab­or­a­tion between MANTIS and the university’s newly ap­pointed Contemporary Ensemble in Residence Psappha.

MANTIS sound diffusion system

As often at these fest­ivals, it was stu­dent works that stood out. The droning, care­lessly as­sembled am­bi­ence of Dominique Bassal’s festival-opening por­trait con­cert on Friday night was quickly over­shad­owed by the work of stu­dents at the NOVARS Research Centre that dis­played varied but con­sist­ently crafted ap­proaches. It is not often that people laugh at the wit of elec­troacoustic music, but Donal Sarsfield’s Of Noise Alone achieves this with a little gentle sub­ver­sion. The work takes the sound of ap­plause and clap­ping as its source ma­terial and, as the audi­ence put their hands to­gether, the piece seemed to re­ignite acous­tic­ally, briefly il­lu­min­ating some­thing faintly ri­dicu­lous about the ritual of per­form­ance and applause.

Irma Catalina Álvarez’s Windslley Street achieves a re­mark­able stead­i­ness and long-breathed form as nu­merous, seem­ingly autonomous little mech­an­isms each follow their own gradual de­vel­op­ment. In stark con­trast to the tend­ency for a ‘whizz bang’, causal lan­guage, this work’s quietude and re­pe­ti­tion man­ages to never seem re­pe­ti­tious while never breaking from a sense of steady progression.

The latest and longest work by Sam Salem, Dead Poets, fur­ther ex­plores his in­terest in using a spe­cific city or place as the acoustic ‘sub­ject’ of a work with a 20-minute, 4-part re­flec­tion on New York. Perhaps Morton Feldman’s title ‘The viola in my life’ — much loved by Helmut Lachenmann — should be ad­apted to this kind of work. Far from being a por­trait or doc­u­mentary of New York this work is per­haps ‘New York in my life’. Again wit was in evid­ence as the story of a tramp un­folds to end with his sorry prot­ag­onist being told to ‘Go fuck your­self’. Some re­mark­able, ominous sounds taken of the wind howling through the shuttered and derelict fair­ground rides of Coney Island com­ple­mented more fa­miliar sounds like subway trains in what seemed an al­to­gether darker work than its ex­cel­lent pre­de­cessor Public Bodies.

As well as other stu­dent works by Oliver Carman, Mark Pilkington, Josh Kopeček and Richard Scott, we were given the chance to hear El Espejo de Alicia by 47-year-old Chilean com­poser Federico Schumacher. Subject of a — by all ac­counts ex­cel­lent — por­trait con­cert at this year’s Festival Acousmatique International in Brussels, Schumacher is not someone I had come across be­fore, but this work was crisp, del­icate and tender, ex­hib­iting both the tech­nical pre­ci­sion we’ve come to ex­pect of this music and — more un­usu­ally — an ear for af­fecting and mu­sical ideas. A lot of his music, in­cluding El Espejo de Alicia, is avail­able for free as mp3s here. I’d re­com­mend a listen.

Live Wires: Psappha & MadLab

Psappha LogoThe Sunday gave us a chance to hear MANTIS’s large rig of loud­speakers pitted against the live in­stru­ments of Psappha’s Tim Williams and Richard Casey in three works for per­cus­sion and piano with elec­tronics. Manuella Blackburn’s Cajon and Joao Pedro Oliveira’s Maelstrom are both ac­com­plished works — the former for the eponymous cajon and the latter for cim­balom — but they were hugely (and per­haps un­sur­pris­ingly) over­shad­owed by Stockhausen’s Kontakte. I heard Kontakte per­formed by Nicolas Hodges and Colin Currie at the Proms in 2008 and found my­self rather ir­rit­ated by it — un­like my re­ac­tion to Gruppen, which was ex­hil­ar­ating — but on Sunday the work’s in­cred­ible, in­ef­fable logic and scope really drove home how short-sighted or simplistic much music for in­stru­ments and elec­tronics is. There is at no point a straight­for­ward concept of in­ter­ac­tion to grasp hold of. Rather, the three parts — piano, per­cus­sion and elec­tronics — are al­lowed to circle each other, finding points of con­tact and drifting apart in a shower of sounds. This is no sound­world piece, it em­braces count­less sounds — with the pi­anist equipped with a per­cus­sion set-up al­most as large as that of the per­cus­sionist — and all the sounds co­exist un­segreg­ated. It is hard to spe­cify how this work holds to­gether. There is some­thing still very con­tem­porary about the con­struc­tion of meta-instruments out of col­lec­tions of per­cus­sion so that a single ges­ture can begin on a guero and end in wind chimes, giving those sounds an or­ganic, phys­ical logic that somehow trans­mits to the acoustic. Casey and Williams’s per­form­ance was grip­ping to the last and it was ex­citing to hear so clearly how im­portant this music is.

MadLab logoSunday evening brought the usual re­laxed fi­nale to the fest­ival, this time re­lo­cated from Nexus Art Café to Manchester Digital Laboratory (MadLab). After a series of fixed media and au­di­ovisual works, we moved onto live per­form­ances with the circuit-bending of Rodrigo Constanzo and Mauricio Pauly, fol­lowed by the synth and video ef­forts of Mark Pilkington and Thomas Bjelkeborn. Reflecting MadLab’s remit of pro­moting com­munity dis­cus­sion and sharing tech­nical ex­pertise, the evening ended with a pre­view screening of a rough cut of Ricardo Climent’s doc­u­mentary film VIP Lounges Are For ALL about S.LOW Projekt, which he ran in Berlin this summer and I wrote about here. A sim­ul­tan­eously hu­morous and ser­ious look at the paradox of working in both aca­demic ‘centres of ex­cel­lence’ and ‘low’ arenas in Berlin’s can-do arts scene, the film poses ques­tions about the quality of art­work and what con­sti­tutes value as well as giving an in­sight as to how this some­what ad hoc, im­pro­vised fest­ival that in­volved around 40 dif­ferent artists ran. Here’s an ex­cerpt to finish off with:

Posted in Musings | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Points of Contact: MANTIS Fall Festival 2010

I’ve been adopted!

Logos of organisations involved with Adopt a Composer: Sound and Music, PRS for Music Foundation, Making Music and King Edward Musical Society.I’m very ex­cited to be able to an­nounce that this year I will be taking part in the Adopt a Composer scheme, funded by the PRS for Music Foundation and run by Sound and Music, in as­so­ci­ation with Making Music. The scheme pairs up com­posers with am­a­teur en­sembles to col­lab­orate on new music and I am de­lighted that I will be working with the or­chestra of King Edward Musical Society in Macclesfield.

In the coming months I will be get­ting to know the or­chestra and working with con­ductor Tony Houghton and my com­pos­i­tion mentor for the pro­ject, David Horne. This col­lab­or­ative pro­cess will result in a per­form­ance on Saturday 18 June 2011 at St Michael and All Angels Church, part of the Macclesfield Barnaby Festival and the cel­eb­ra­tion of the 750th an­niversary of the town’s royal charter. It will be my first work for or­chestra, an ex­citing learning pro­cess — quite pos­sibly for the or­chestra as much as for me — and I’m looking for��ward to it immensely.

Macclesfield Barnaby Festival

Posted in News | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on I’ve been adopted!
  • Microbiography

    Chris Swithinbank is a British-Dutch com­poser who works with both acoustic in­stru­ments and elec­tronic sounds. He is cur­rently a stu­dent at Harvard University with Chaya Czernowin.
    Full Biography »

  • Hear